Sports Memorabilia as an Alternative Investment

Sports Memorabilia as an Alternative Investment

Mar 4, 2009 | Sports Collectibles

A press release from last fall, but perhaps still relevant:

“At a time of sinking home and stock prices, investors are eager to find financial safe havens. While sports memorabilia may not be as sound an investment as bonds or a bank deposit, the returns can sometimes be breathtaking.

New York, NY (PRWEB) September 14, 2008 — Collectors have been trading sports memorabilia since the early 1900s when Babe Ruth trading cards were swapped and sold. Today, sports memorabilia is a multi-million dollar global industry. Collectors have made big profits by trading items autographed by the world’s greatest sports stars.

The highest price paid for a piece of sporting memorabilia is $2.8 million for a Honus Wagner baseball card. Wagner was a baseball star in the early 20th century and the card dates to between 1909 and 1911. Hockey superstar Wayne Gretzky bought the Wagner card in 1991 for $451,000 and later sold it to Walmart for $500,000. In 1995 Walmart made the card its top prize in a raffle, won by a Florida postal worker. A year later the card was sold at auction for $640,000. In 2000 it was sold again, this time on ebay for $1.27 million. Then, in February 2007 the card changed hands for $2.35 million, only to be sold 6 months later to a collector in California for a whopping $2.8 million.

The Honus Wagner card showed an annual rate of return of 12% between 1991 and 2007. Not bad when compared with the Dow Jones Industrial which returned 7.5% per annum over the same period. But a word of warning before you go buying up all the Honus Wagner cards you can lay your hands on. It has to be the right Honus Wagner card. A collector in Kansas recently sold a card on ebay for only $3.25.

Memorabilia from other sports can also be big business. A football (soccer) shirt worn by Pele fetched a record 157,750 pounds ($276,062), a lot of 6,000 pro football signatures sold for $22,417 and a Michael Jordan game jersey was valued at over $6,000.

There is also money to be made at the smaller end of the market. At time of writing there were over 690,000 sports memorabilia items listed on ebay with prices from $52,000 to one penny.

As with all investments the trick is in spotting good value. Prices for sports memorabilia can be fickle with demand rising and falling with a sports-persons career.

If you are buying sports memorabilia be sure to differentiate between official memorabilia and the rest. Official memorabilia will come with a Certificate of Authenticity (COA). There are many sources of COA’s so be sure you are buying from a reputable source.”

0 Comments

0 Comments

Action Comics #1

Most Valuable Comic Book Currently

Action Comics No. 1 (DC Comics, 1938) regains the throne (First published January 18, 2026) In the see-saw battle for most valuable comic book, Metropolis/ComicConnect has reported a private sale for $15 million for an Action Comics #1 CGC 9.0, setting a new record...

Collectible Update

Top Trends in Collectibles 2025

In 2025, the collectibles market saw strong performance in physical items, particularly trading cards, toys, and sports memorabilia, while digital collectibles (NFTs) experienced a market cool-down. Trends were driven by cultural moments, nostalgia, and a growing...

Vinyl Record Resurgence

Vinyl Record Resurgence

Gen Z’s look at record albums as “Affordable Art” We have noticed the past uptick on sales for record albums and apparently there are a few variables driving the market. Gen Z is a major driver of the vinyl record resurgence, contributing...

More Collectible News

T206 Sweet Caporal Honus Wagner Coming to Auction

Unarguably One of the Holy Grails of Sports Trading Card Collectibles Goldin Auctions will be auctioning a rare T206 Honus Wagner in January of 2026 (link here) that has a fascinating backstory. According to Goldin: “Graded a PSA PR 1, it emphatically boasts one...

Tom Brady 2000 Bowman Chrome Rookie Card #236

Over the past year, Tom Brady’s 2000 Bowman Chrome rookie card has seen a significant jump in value. We were recently alerted about this card in a news story posted by Horacio Ruiz on the Sports Illustrated website (si.com). To quote: “Tom Brady has a few...

Shohei Ohtani Baseball Cards are on Fire

Bowman Chrome Gold Refractor Rookie Card sells for $60,000 While heartbreaking for us Canadian Blue Jays fans, the recent World Series highlighted who I am calling the “Japanese Baseball Jesus” – Shohei Ohtani, who with his two-way superstar status...

Most Expensive Sports Card Ever Sold

1952 Topps Mickey Mantle #311 Today on August 28, 2022 a new record was set for not only the most expensive sports trading card, but the highest priced piece of sports memorabilia ever sold - eclipsing the T-206 Honus Wagner card which sold earlier in August for $7.25...